Friday, February 04, 2005

Damage control

Lately I've been reminding myself more and more frequently that things usually work out over time and as a quasi-leader of the teachers on my hall I have an obligation to remain objective, calm and not perpetuate any panic or hostility that may arise. I also have to remind myself not to get the urge to run screaming into the sunset myself. Within the past two weeks two teachers have stated their intent to resign at the end of the year. The primary reason for their decision is boiled down to an administration that wants to micro-manage their grading policies and will do anything to keep a disgruntled parent happy. Although both of these teachers are new to the school they are experienced teachers and have high standards for students to achieve. Not unreasonably high standards, mind you. Both of them have had to drop grades, allow zero grades to be made up and basically had all of their authority and credibility with both parents and students pulled out from under them. This has had a chilling and demoralizing effect on the other teachers. At least four other teachers have privately told me that they will seek transfers at the end of the year. Although I haven't really had the situation over grades that they have had, I have had my credibility with students pretty well dented by an administrator who wanted to over-ride me and judge individual situations on a case by case basis. Even students can quickly realize that maybe it's their lucky day, or maybe it's not depending on the administrators current level of tension.
I wonder that he cannot seem to see where this will lead...teachers who have decided to do grade inflation rather than have to go toe-to-toe to defend an assignment rubric or a discipline decision. Students and parents who will routinely circumvent the teacher in hopes of a more favorable decision from the administration will begin to clog the office and slow down the really necessary administrative tasks. My biggest fear is that we will have created an environment where there are no boundaries that are dependable and the perception will become the biggest squealer will get the grease. Changing and dropping grades to suit one parent whose little darling didn't quite make the grade will be categorically unfair to others who through deligent effort achieved an earned success. Even worse, those who don't know how to go about makeing a fuss will lose out on the benefits enjoyed by those with the pushy parents.
I wish parents weren't so myopic. They seem to only be able to see the immediate frustration or disappointment of their child and their knee-jerk response is to do anything to fix it. They seem incapable of seeing the bigger picture...the long term goal of allowing children to make mistakes, suffer consequences and learn from them. What do they think they are teaching a child when they bully the teacher into giving the child an undeserved grade?
I'm not quite sure how to mitigate the growing storm.

2 Comments:

At 5:21 PM, Blogger Brillig said...

Is this a single administrator’s view, or is this a standard practice held by the entire school board? If letting kids go on with out working is as common as you make it sound then I would say that the system is flawed. Has the numbers of kids and parents who “bully” the system increased over the years you have been working as a teacher? Or has it merely stayed the same? If the numbers haven’t risen then maybe the administration is just letting these kids slide to avoid any possible legal trouble and this is just an acceptable allowance of incidences. Maybe they should rework K-12 grade schools to be more like colleges. If a child fails they don’t need to be held back but now they have to attend a school (like Independence) after their regular school day ends. With this method no child would ever “fail” they would just have to rank up to the appropriate level of classes passed. Then the administrators could say, “Sorry Mr. Smith but little Billy here decided to screw around in class last year so he can’t do any intramurals this year. He’ll have to go down the street after classes to make up for math.”

 
At 6:27 PM, Blogger cj said...

No, I wouldn't say it's a single administrator's view since I have seen it happen several times before the recent change in administrators. Has parental bllying increased? No, probably not. We all expect there will be a few disgruntled parents each year who tend to target the teachers every year for their child's non-performance. I don't agree that there should be an allowable level of kids we let slide to avoid legal entanglements. If we do everything we are supposed to do we shouldn't fear legal repercussions. Of course, as you know, kids in high school who fail a course have to go to an extended day program to make it up or attend summer school. We don't have extended day programs in middle school. Maybe we should. They CAN attend summer school but that only makes up two classes. Here's an example of where I feel it goes wrong: R____ failed four subjects last year in 8th grade. I know he was SUPPOSED to go to summer school but I don't know if he did. Even so, he could only make up 2 of the four he failed. Therefore he was "placed" in 9th, not promoted. His first semester grades as a 9th grade student show him failing ALL of his classes! Now, did we do the right thing? He's not the only one. There were approximately 7 others that I know of where the situation was the same. O.K., seven out of 270 is probably not a bad record but I'm looking at the end result for each and every one of those seven kids.
The problem as I see it, is that teachers will begin to see no reason to accurately assess kids skills through grading. What's the point? The other teacher in my subject area decided to tell her students that if they passed the first semester final exam, she would pass them for first semester no matter what their grade average was. For at least a few of her students that gave them a 40 point jump in grade due to one test! I can't quite bring myself to cheat kids out of an education that way but then again, she's in her classroom while I'm sitting in yet another pointless meeting with parents who have no intention of getting their kid to straighten up.
AAAARRRRGGGHHH!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home